Written by: Brian Egy, Vice President, Property Tax
For many organizations, property taxes are one of the largest ongoing operating expenses. Yet assessed values are often accepted without question, even as market conditions may shift in a meaningful way. At the center of that disconnect is a concept that is frequently overlooked but highly consequential: economic obsolescence. When assessed values are not properly identified and measured, they can quickly become misaligned with the fair market value, leading to unnecessary tax burden.
What Economic Obsolescence Really Means in Property Tax
Economic obsolescence is a loss in value caused by external forces beyond the control of the property owner. These forces can include changes in market demand, capital markets, industry performance, or regulatory environments.
Unlike physical depreciation or functional issues, there is nothing inherently wrong with the property itself. In fact, a newly constructed, well-designed asset can still experience significant value decline if the broader market suddenly moves against it.
That distinction matters. While most assessments account for physical deterioration and some level of functional inefficiency, they often fail to appropriately capture what is happening outside the four walls of the property.
A Market-Driven Reality Across All Property Types
Economic obsolescence in property tax is not limited to distressed assets or niche industries. It is a market-driven phenomenon that can affect virtually any property type.
Office buildings face reduced demand as workplace strategies evolve. Retail properties continue to adapt to changing consumer behavior. Industrial and manufacturing assets respond to supply and demand imbalances. Even high-growth sectors like data centers and renewable energy are influenced by technology shifts, pricing pressures, and regulatory changes.
The common thread is simple: value is shaped by the market, not just the asset.
Where Property Assessments Fall Short
Many jurisdictions rely heavily on the Cost Approach to estimate value, starting with replacement cost and adjusting for depreciation and obsolescence. While that framework is sound in theory, the execution often falls short in practice.
Economic obsolescence is difficult to measure. It requires market-level analysis, industry context, and data that goes beyond standard mass appraisal models. As a result, it is frequently understated or omitted altogether. When that happens, the outcome is predictable. Assessed values drift away from actual market conditions, and they no longer reconcile with income performance or comparable sales. The burden then shifts to the taxpayer to quantify this discrepancy.
The Financial Impact of Getting It Wrong
When economic obsolescence is not properly recognized, the effects are immediate and measurable.
Assessed values become inflated. Property taxes increase beyond what the market supports. Operating expenses rise, compressing cash flow and net operating income. Over time, this impacts not just annual budgets, but overall asset value and portfolio performance.
For organizations managing large or complex portfolios, even modest misalignment in valuation assumptions can translate into significant dollars.
Why Economic Obsolescence in Property Tax is Often Missed
Economic obsolescence is often overlooked because it is harder to see. It does not show up in a property inspection. It cannot be resolved through a capital improvement. And it often requires a combination of market data, financial analysis, and industry expertise to quantify in a defensible way.
Without that level of analysis, assessments tend to default to cost-based conclusions that do not fully reflect real-world conditions.
Why It Matters Now
In today’s environment, external pressures like interest rate volatility, shifting demand patterns, evolving technologies, and regulatory changes are actively reshaping property values across industries. These are precisely the conditions in which economic obsolescence is most relevant and impactful. Ignoring it does not make the risk go away—it simply embeds that risk into the assessed value.
Our Approach to Economic Obsolescence in Property Tax
DMA views economic obsolescence as a critical component of accurate, defensible property valuation. Our approach goes beyond standard assessment review to evaluate the full economic context surrounding each asset.
That includes analyzing market trends, industry performance, and asset-level financial data to identify where external forces are impacting value. Just as importantly, we translate those findings into clear, supportable positions that can be effectively communicated during the appeals process.
The goal is not just to challenge an assessment, but to align it with reality.
Take the Next Step
If your property has been assessed without a clear evaluation of economic obsolescence, there is a strong possibility that the value may not reflect current market conditions. DMA can help you identify and quantify those external factors and pursue a more accurate, defensible assessment.
eastBefore making any decision or taking any action based upon information contained on this website, you should consult with a DMA professional.